Una ridotta capacità delle NK di uccidere cellule invase da virus (vedi figura) è stata dimostrata in più studi sulla ME/CFS. In particolare, ben 16 studi hanno dimostrato una ridotta citotossicità delle NK quando le cellule K562 siano usate come bersaglio (IOM, 2015). Uno dei primi studi in merito credo sia quello di Caligiuri e colleghi del 1987 (Caligiuri et al., 1987). In seguito si poté chiarire che questa difettosa citotossicità risulta legata a una ridotta concentrazione intracellulare (nelle NK) di perforina (Maher et al., 2005), l’enzima che tanto le NK che le T CD8+ usano per indurre l’apopotosi delle cellule infette. In studi ancora posteriori è stato accertato sorprendentemente che, a fronte di una concentrazione ridotta di perforina, si ha un aumento della espressione di RNA messaggero relativo a questa molecola, sempre nelle NK (Brenu EW, 2011). E’ come se le NK tentassero di aumentare la concentrazione intracellulare di perforina, senza riuscirci. Ebbene, è stato dimostrata in vitro la capacità dell’Ampligen di migliorare il funzionamento delle NK provenienti da pazienti CFS (Strayer et al., 2015). Sfortunatamente non esistono dati in vivo, tuttavia anche la misura della citotossicità delle NK sembra avere il potenziale di identificare un gruppo di pazienti che potrebbero beneficiare del farmaco. Si consideri inoltre che la citotossicità delle NK è ridotta anche in altre patologie, come il lupus eritematoso sistemico e la sindrome di Sjögren (Struyf NG et al. 1990).
In Italia la misurazione della “citotossicità spontanea delle NK” (utilizzando cellule K562 come bersaglio) è un esame previsto in molte regioni (se non tutte) e tabulato con codice 90.59.3 e costa una ventina di euro (vedi link per Lombardia). Può essere eseguito presso il Policlinico Umberto Primo di Roma (UOC Immunologia e Immunopatologia). In figura 1 sono riportati i livelli di citotossicità di tre pazienti, confrontati con due controlli sani. La citotossicità è calcolata come percentuale di cellule bersagio uccise e viene riportata per diversi valori del rapporto seguente:
numero di cellule effettrici/numero di cellule bersaglio
Considera una donazione per sostenere questo blog.
In the chart you find below I collected the single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) that have been associated with ME/CFS byGriffith University’s researchers, to the extent that they are included in the SNPs read by the common23ndME genetic test. Between 2015 and 2016 the research team published at least four genetics studies, identifying a total of 65 SNPs associated with ME/CFS (Johnston S, Staines D et al. 2016), (Marshall-Gradisnik S, Huth T et al. 2016), (Marshall-Gradisnik S, Johnston S et al. 2016), (Marshall-Gradisnik S, Smith P et al. 2015). Of these, only 23 match the data provided by the 23andME test. In the chart I report these 23 SNPs, their frequency in healthy controls (HC) and patients (CFS), Odd Ratios (OR) and p-values; in addition, I report the respective base pairs for three patients (Pt. 1, 2, 3). In yellow are the genotypes mainly associated with the pathology, in green those that seem to have a protective role against the pathology. For studies no. 1, 2 and 3 I reported the ORs, whereas for study no. 4 I reported the p-values. ORs greater than 1 indicate the genotype’s association with the pathology; ORs less than 1 indicate its protective role against the pathology. P-values less than 0.05 indicate genotypes associated with the pathology.
Alpha-adrenergic receptor 1
AA genotype for rs2322333 in adrenergic receptor α1 (ADRA1A) has been demonstrated to have a protective role against ME/CFS (Johnston S, Staines D et al. 2016). As shown in the chart, none of the three patients is a carrier for this genotype. ADRA1A receptors are involved in vasoconstriction of blood vessels throughout the body, including the skin, gastrointestinal system, genitourinary system, kidney, and brain. In the brain, these receptors exert effects on the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenocortical (HPA) axis and in motor functions. In ME/CFS orthostatic intolerance (POTS and/or orthostatic hypotension) is frequent to be found: in fact, this symptom is featured in the diagnostic criteria (IOM, 2015). Midodrine, an agonist of he ADRA1A receptor, has been suggested as a treatment for ME/CFS in a case study (Naschitz J et al 2004). Bearing all the above in mind, position rs2322333 may be linked to some important mechanism at the core of ME/CFS.
Figure. TRPM3 gene expression in different human tissues.
Nicotinic cholinergic receptors ACHRN
As shown in the chart, patient no. 1 presents two polymorphisms in the gene for nicotinic acetylcholine receptor alpha-2 subunit (ACHRN2), which are associated with ME/CFS. Nicotinic acetylcholine receptors are found both in Peripheral Nervous System (sympathetic and parasympathetic) and in the neuromuscular junction. They are present in the Central Nervous System too. Moreover, the alpha-2 subunit is expressed also by various lymphocytes (B cells, T cells, monocytes), and the same applies to the beta-4 subunit, which presents potentially pathogenic polymorphisms in patient no. 2 and 3. Eventual vulnerabilities in these receptors may lead to countless effects: they may, for example, constitute a predisposing risk factor for orthostatic intolerance, a main feature of ME/CFS. Besides, pyridostigmine, a cholinesterase inhibitor, the enzyme involved in degradation of acetylcholine, has been successfully used in at least one study on ME/CFS patients (Kawamura Y et al. 2003).
TRPM3 ionic channels
Griffith University has published two studies arguing for a connection between ME/CFS and impaired transient receptor potential melastatin 3 (TRPM3) calcium channels. After demonstrating a significant reduction in TRPM3 cell surface expression in NK in patients, compared to healthy controls (Nguyen T et al. 2016), researchers have proved this abnormality to impact calcium influx in NK and postulated this mechanism as the very cause of the reduced NK cytotoxicity observed in numerous studies. Being TRPM3 expressed in many tissues (sensory neurons, kidneys, brain, hypophysis, pancreas: see figure), researchers have suggested its malfunction to be the physiological basis of ME/CFS (Nguyen T et al. 2016). In addition, given previous data (by the same research team) regarding the statistic association between ME/CFS and TRPM3 polymorphisms (Johnston S, Staines D et al. 2016), (Marshall-Gradisnik S, Huth T et al. 2016), (Marshall-Gradisnik S, Johnston S et al. 2016), the authors have suggested this dysfunction to be possibly due to a genetic predisposition. Looking at our three patients, each one of them is a carrier for at least one genetic variant of TRPM3 associated with ME/CFS. Particularly, genotype CT in rs1328153 position is present in all of them.
Some days ago I wrote a letter to a researcher who is currently involved in the study of ME/CFS. I sent him some relatively rare genetic variants that I had found analyzing my own exome and the one of another patient (see this post). He was so kind to reply to my mail. He answered with a simple and – at the same time – very interesting note. If there was a genetic predisposition to ME/CFS – he observed – it would be common, very prevalent in the general population. Otherwise, we could not explain the epidemic episodes of the disease, like the one that happened in Lake Tahoe (Nevada), or in Lyndonville (New York), or in Bergen (Norway), and so forth. He left me with this problem “to think at night”, as he wrote.
Well, I did my homework. A genetic predisposition to ME/CFS has been suggested by a study on familial clustering of ME/CFS from a data bank of Utah health care system. They have found a significant increase in ME/CFS relative risk among first, second, and third degree relatives, compared with the general population (Albright F. et al. 2011). The problem is: acknowledged a genetic predisposition, how prevalent is it?
In 2004, a large outbreak of Giardia duodenalis struck the city of Bergen, in Norway. Of 1252 laboratory-confirmed cases, 347 reported chronic fatigue three years later. 53 of them were selected for a study and 41.5% of them were found to fit the criteria for ME/CFS (Mørch K et al. 2013). If we assume the same percentage for all the 347 patients who were symptomatic three years after the outbreak, we find that 144 of the original cases of laboratory-confirmed infection developed ME/CFS. This points to a prevalence of 11,5% in general population for the genetic predisposition to ME/CFS.
In order to confirm this result, I then considered a very well known study on the prevalence of ME/CFS among Australian patients who went to their doctor for infections due to Epstein-Barr virus, Coxiella burnetii, and Ross River virus. They found that after six months from the infection, 28/253 participants (11%) met the diagnostic criteria for ME/CFS (Hickie I. et al. 2006). So we find a slightly lower prevalence in this case, but we should consider that in the second study the diagnosis was made after six months from the infection, while in the first paper the clinical picture was evaluated after three years. The difference could be due to a certain degree of spontaneous recovery (4% of patients?) that has been reported (anectodal) during the first years from the beginning of the disease.
The conclusion of this very short and poor analysis is that if there was a genetic predisposition, it would be present in 11% of the general population. And yet, ME/CFS is much less prevalent. But if we consider the two studies mentioned, we could argue that we need a major infection (one that requires medical care and blood tests) in order to trigger this predisposition. So we would have a genetic predisposition highly prevalent (1 in 10 individuals!) but with low penetrance (only a small percentage of those who carry the genetic predisposition ends up developing the disease).
Now, if we assume that the genes involved in this predisposition are n and that these genes are transmitted independently one from another, then we have:
p_1 × p_2 × … × p_n = 0.11
where p_i is the prevalence of the variation on the i-th gene involved. This means that if we assume that the genetic predisposition is due to two or more genes, then each of these variants has a prevalence higher than 0.33.
We present an attempt at exome analysis in two ME/CFS patients. Pt. 1 presents a mild form of carboxypeptidase N (CPN1) deficiency (a missense in exon 3) while Pt. 2 revealed two rare intronic variants in the same gene. CPN1 is an enzyme that inactivates kinins and complement proteins split products (such as C4a, a known anaphylatoxin). Therefore, CPN1 deficiency could explain C4a increase after exercise and mast cell abnormalities previously reported in ME/CFS. It could also explain the high prevalence of POTS in ME/CFS since kinins are vasodilators.
Myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS) is a debilitating disease characterized by cognitive deficits, fatigue, orthostatic intolerance with symptoms exacerbated after exertion (IOM, 2015). This disease has no known cause but several abnormalities have been observed in energy metabolism (Tomas C. and Newton J. 2018), immune system and gut flora (Blomberg J. et al. 2018), brain (Zeineh MM. et al. 2014). In this population of patients, several abnormalities have been found to be triggered by exercise, such as abnormal aerobic performance (Snell C. et al. 2013), enhanced gene expression of specific receptors (White AT. et al. 2012), abnormal gut flora translocation (Shukla SK et al. 2015) and failure in blood clearance of complement protein 4 split product A (C4a) (Sorensen B et al. 2003). An increase in C4a is part of the human physiologic response to physical exercise, but these levels return to baseline within 30 minutes to 2 hours (Dufaux B et al. 1991) while in ME/CFS there is a peak in serum C4a six hours after exertion. A possible explanation for slow C4a inactivation could be a problem in carboxypeptidase N (CPN1), an enzyme involved in the inactivation of C3a, C4a, C5a. CPN1 is required for kinins inactivation too, such as bradykinin, kalladin (Hugli T. 1978), (Plummer TH et Hurwitz MY 1978), that are vasodilators. We report on the case of a ME/CFS patient (Pt. 1) with a missense variant in CPN1 gene that is linked to reduced function of the enzyme and of another ME/CFS patient (Pt. 2) with rare variants in introns 1 and 6 of the same gene with uncertain significance (table 1, figure 1).
Materials and Methods
Whole exome sequencing (WES) has been performed on cells from the saliva of two ME/CFS patients, with an average 100X coverage (Dante Labs). The first search for pathogenic variants and insertions/deletions was performed with the software EVE, provided by Sequencing.com. A further refinement of the search was conducted by manual insertion of these SNPs in VarSome. The search for possible unknown pathogenic variants within the gene for CPN1 has been performed using Integrative Genome Viewer (IGV), an opensource tool for genetic data analysis.
Results from the analysis of the two exomes performed with EVE and refined with VarSome are collected in table 2 (Pt. 1) and table 3 (Pt. 2).
Pt. 2 is carrier of a mitochondrial disease (table 3, first line): a missense in gene for medium-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (MCAD) which leads to mild functional impairment of the enzyme involved in the oxidation of fatty acids (44% residual activity) (Koster KL. et al. 2014).
Pt. 2 is also homozygous for a variation in gene arylsulfatase A (ARSA) that is linked to a residual activity of only 10% of normal (Gomez-Ospina N. 2010). Arylsulfatase A deficiency (also known as metachromatic leukodystrophy or MLD) is a disorder of impaired breakdown of sulfatides (cerebroside sulfate or 3-0-sulfo-galactosylceramide), sulfate-containing lipids that occur throughout the body and are found in greatest abundance in nervous tissue, kidneys, and testes. Sulfatides are critical constituents in the nervous system, where they comprise approximately 5% of the myelin lipids. Sulfatide accumulation in the nervous system eventually leads to myelin breakdown (leukodystrophy) and a progressive neurologic disorder (Von Figura et al 2001). Nevertheless, this genotype does not cause MLD, and this benign condition of reduced ARSA activity is called ARSA pseudodeficiency. There are about 4 homozygotes in 1000 persons among non-Finnish Europeans (VarSome)
Pt. 1 is a carrier of a missense in gene CPN1 (table 2, first line) which leads to a loss of more than 60% of activity, according to a study on a single patient (Mathews KP. et al. 1980), (Cao H. et Hegele RA. 2003). The study of gene CPN1 in both patients (using IGV) has led to the identification of two rare variants (frequency less than 0.002) in intron 1 and 6 of one allele from Pt. 2 (table 1, figure 1). In MCAD no other damaging variations have been identified in these two patients by direct inspection with IGV (data not shown).
Whole exome sequencing (WES) is a technique that aims at the sequencing of the fraction of our genome that encodes for proteins: about 30 million base pairs (1% of the all the human DNA) divided into about 20 thousand genes (Ng SB et al. 2009). It has become increasingly clear that the use of WES can positively improve the rate of diagnosis and decrease the time needed for a definitive diagnosis in patients with rare genetic diseases (Sawyer SL et al. 2016). WES also positively impacts the ability to discover new pathogenic variants in known disease genes (Polychronakos C. et Seng KC. 2011) and the discovery of completely new disease genes (Boycott KM 2013). ME/CFS seems to have a genetic component: a US study found clear evidence of familial clustering and elevated risk for the disease among relatives of ME/CFS cases (Albright F et al. 2011) and several SNPs in various genes have been reported as more prevalent in ME/CFS patients versus healthy controls (Wang T et al. 2017). And yet, no studies that analyzed whole exomes of ME/CFS patients have been published, to my knowledge.
In this study, we searched for known genetic diseases in the exomes of two ME/CFS patients who fit the IOM criteria for SEID (IOM, 2015), with postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS) identified by positive tilt table test. We detected a missense variant in CPN1 (rs61751507) in Pt. 1 (heterozygosis) that has been associated to a loss of activity of the enzyme of at least 60% in a previous study (Mathews KP. et al. 1980), (Cao H. et Hegele RA. 2003). We then found that, although Pt. 2 was not a carrier of this SNP, she had two rare SNPs in intron 1 (rs188667294) and 6 (rs113386068) of gene CPN1 (both present in less than 1/500 alleles, table 1, figure 1). These intronic variations have not been studied, to our knowledge, so their pathogenicity can’t be excluded at present. Variations in introns can be damaging just as missense and nonsense mutations in exons; suffice to say that the main known pathogenic SNP of gene CPN1 is a substitution in intron 1 (Cao H. et Hegele RA. 2003).
Carboxypeptidase N (CPN1) is an enzyme involved in the inactivation of C3a, C4a, C5a, and of kinins (bradykinin, kalladin) (Hugli T. 1978), (Plummer TH et Hurwitz MY 1978). In ME/CFS the physiologic increase in blood of C4a (the split product of the complement protein C4) after exercise is significantly more pronounced than in healthy controls as if there was a defect in C4a inactivation (Sorensen B et al. 2003). Such a defect could very well be a loss of function in CPN1, as found in Pt 1. Moreover, CPN1 is involved in inactivation of bradykinin, which is known to induce vasodilatation (Siltari A. et al. 2016), therefore CPN1 deficiency could play a role in POTS and in orthostatic intolerance in general. Both patients have a tilt table test positive for POTS. C4a has been recently considered to play a causal role in the cognitive deficit of schizophrenia, because of its role in synapsis pruning (Sekar, A et al, 2016); therefore a failure in its inactivation could be implicated in the incapacitating cognitive defects lamented by ME/CFS patients.
Only two patients with CPN1 deficiency have been reported so far in medical literature (Mathews KP. et al. 1980), (Willemse Jl et al. 2008), and the enzymatic defect has been associated to angioedema that most often involved the face and tongue, urticaria, and hay fever and asthma precipitated by exercise. This clinical presentation could be due, at least in part, to mast cell activation: in fact, C4a is a known anaphylatoxin that induces mast cells degranulation and release of histamine (Erdei A. et al. 2004). That said, we can observe that even if the clinical presentation of the only two known cases of CPN1 deficiency doesn’t fit the clinical picture of ME/CFS, mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS) has some commonalities with ME/CFS (Theoharides, TC et al. 2005), and mast cell abnormalities have been reported among ME/CFS patients (Nguyen T. et al. 2016). So we can’t exclude that activation of mast cells by a failure in C4a inactivation may lead to ME/CFS symptoms. The role of exercise as a trigger for symptoms in CPN1 deficiency is also highly suggestive because this is a pathognomonic feature of ME/CFS.
CPN1 deficiency is present (even if in a mild form) in Pt. 1, while Pt. 2 presents two rare intronic variants whose pathogenic role can’t be excluded. CPN1 deficiency could explain the abnormal increase of C4a after exercise and might be a contributing factor to post-exertional malaise and cognitive symptoms in ME/CFS. A search for pathogenetic SNPs in gene CPN1 among ME/CFS patients would clarify the role (if any) of this gene.
Acknowledgments. I would like to thank Chiara Scarpellini for her careful collection of annotations for each of the 2 hundred or so variants found by EVE within the exomes of Pt. 1 and Pt. 2 (table 2 and table 3).
A translation to Dutch of this article is available here.
During the Community Symposium on the molecular basis of ME/CFS (R) two different groups of researchers reported on an increased level of antibodies to beta adrenergic and muscarinic receptors in sera from ME/CFS patients vs healthy controls (Figure 1). These new data have been collected independently by Alan Light (University of Utah) and Jonas Bergquist (Uppsala Universitet). Bergquist also reported that these autoantibodies can’t be found in cerebrospinal fluid from ME/CFS patients.
What was already known on these autoantibodies
The presence of a higher than normal reactivity of sera from ME/CFS patients to muscarinic receptors was reported for the first time by a Japanese group, more than a decade ago (Tanaka S et al. 2003) and it has been confirmed recently in a work by Osaka City University Graduate School of Medicine (Yamamoto S et al. 2012) and in another paper by University of Bergen (Norway) and Charité University (Germany) (Loebel M et al. 2016). In particular, while Tanaka and colleagues measured an increased level of autoantibodies against muscarinic cholinergic receptor 1 (CHRM1) in about half of patients, the European group described an increase in reactivity of sera to subtypes M3 and M4, in a subset of patients (Figure 2). They used two completely different assays, as we will see later, and this might be the reason for the different results.
As you can see from figure 2, the study by Loebel et al. also indicated an increase in antibodies to beta adrenergic receptors (subtype 2), in agreement with the latest data from Light and Bergquist. In this regard, it is worth noting that autoantibodies to muscarinic receptors M2 and M3, and to beta adrenergic receptors (subtype 1 and 2) have been already reported in orthostatic hypotension (OH) (Yu X et al. 2012), (Li H et al. 2012) and that antibodies to beta 2 adrenergic receptors have been identified in patients with postural-orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS) (Li et al. 2014). This means that this group of autoantibodies is associated with orthostatic intolerance (POTS and/or OH), but orthostatic intollerance is part of the clinical picture of ME/CFS (IOM 2015) and those patients who have a diagnosis of POTS often have many features in common with ME/CFS patients, see for instance (Okamoto L et al. 2012), (Wise S et al. 2015). So, it might be conceivable that these autoantibodies play a role in the pathogenesis of some symptoms in a subgroup of patients, although this has not been proven, so far.
We don’t know the reason why the immune system of some ME/CFS patients reacts with these receptors, but Alan Light suggested, during the symposium, that a possible source for these antibodies might be a mechanism known with the name of molecular mimicry (MM). The basic idea behind MM is that B cells can erroneously produce antibodies to human proteins when epitopes of an infectious agent closely resemble epitopes found in the host (Rose NR 1998). MM is currently believed to explain the pathogenesis of Guillain-Barré syndrome, where lipo-oligosaccharides on the Campylobacter jejunii outer membrane seems to elicit (in predisposed individuals) an immune response to human gangliosides, due to the similarity between these antigens (Van den Berg B et al. 2014). Now, if molecular mimicry was involved in the origin of antibodies to beta 2 adrenergic receptors, which could be the epitope on the receptor? And which the pathogen-borne antigen? In order to provide a possible answer to this question we have to consider that the regions of a receptor that can be involved in B cell autoimmunity are only those that have extracellular exposure; the other regions are immersed in plasma membrane and in cytoplasm, so they can’t interact with antibodies. As you can see from Figure 3, beta 2 adrenergic receptor (ADRB2) has four extracellular regions, in particular peptides 1-34, 96-106, 175-196, 299-305. In general, epitopes are mainly conformational and that means that they are regions of the protein surface, produced by the folding of the protein itself. Nevertheless, in our example we will search only for linear epitopes.
I have used QuickBLASTP provided by NCBI, with default settings (E=100, a word of 6 letters, BLOSUM62 as substitution matrix) and I have considered for each of the four extracellular peptides both the sequence of residues from the N-terminus to the C-terminus, and the inverted sequence. We obtain as the only match the protein sensor histidine kinase MtrB belonging to Pseudonocardia sp. Ae331_Ps2 (R) (Figure 4). I can’t find this particular protein in UniProt, but if it was a membrane protein and if peptide 67-77 was exposed to the extracellular space, this peptide could perhaps be a candidate as a trigger for anti-ADRB2, according to the MM theory. It is important to note here that although molecular mimicry is a popular theory (perhaps because of its simplicity) it has been proven to be a cause of autoimmnity only in Guillain-Barré syndrome.
So, what about a test for these autoantibodies?
If antibodies to adrenergic and muscarinc receptors were involved in the pathogenesis of some cases of ME/CFS, it would be interesting for patients to test for them. In this regard, it is worth noting that the measure of antibodies to membrane receptors should be done using an assay in which these receptors are expressed by living cells in their physiological position (CBA, cell based assay). In fact, with assays in which receptors are coated on plates we may have both false positives (due to the fact that sera react with peptides that are not in the extracellular domain) and false negatives (due to protein denaturation, which leads to the formation of epitopes that would not be present if the protein were correctly folded). The superiority of CBA over the other kind of test is well accepted in the case of anti-MOG antibodies (Ramanathan S et al 2016). It is worth noting that both the study by Loebel et al. and the previous one (Tanaka et al.) used recombinat proteins coated on plates. As far as I know, there are no commercial CBA assays for anti-muscarinic cholinergic receptors and beta adrenergic receptors, at present. The only assay available does not seem to be a CBA, from the provided documentation (R).
In silico experiment
We will now try to simulate what could happen with a test for the search of anti-ADB2R antibodies, if the protein was coated on a plate. We will use the prediction of DiscoTope 2.0, which is a software that calculates all possible B cell epitopes of a given protein, using both the geometry of the protein (in particular a parameter called protrusion index, calculated from the protein’s ellipsoid of inertia) and statistical data on known B cell epitopes (Kringelum, et al., 2012). If we use the 3D structure of ADB2R experimentally determined in (Rasmussen et al. 2007) with standard settings, DiscoTope predicts peptide 231-242 as the only possible epitope (consider that the experimental 3D structure of ADB2R is incomplete). As you can see from figure 5 this peptide belongs to the intracellular domain of the receptor and so it by no means could be a B cell epitope, in vivo. In conclusion, according to this simulation, there is a risk of false positive results with any test that uses recombinat ADB2R coated on a plate.
Una decina delle 21 specie di batteri appartenenti al genere Bartonella sono potenzialmente in grado di generare infezioni sintomatiche negli esseri umani, con manifestazioni che possono avere gravità variabile: da malattie che si risolvono spontaneamente a condizioni che mettono a repentaglio la vita del paziente. Anche la durata può variare, da infezioni acute di qualche giorno a infezioni croniche (Mogollon-Pasapera E et al. 2009).
Malattia da graffio del gatto e altre manifestazioni
La più nota di queste patologie è forse la “malattia da graffio del gatto” (cat-scratch diesease) dovuta a Bartonella henselae e trasmessa agli uomini dai gatti, attraverso morsi o graffi. La trasmissione da gatto a gatto avviene attraverso le pulci (Ctenocephalides felis) e il 50% dei gatti domestici è portatore sano di questo patogeno (Massei F et al. 2005). In genere la malattia da graffio del gatto si limita ad avere una manifestazione locale e si risolve da sola; in altri casi può avere manifestazioni sistemiche quali febbre, mal di testa, fatica, e perdita di appetito. Il trattamento – se richiesto – può andare da 5 giorni di azitromicina per le forme lievi, a una combinazione di doxiciclina (o eritromicina) e rifampicina per 1-2 mesi, per le forme neurologiche (Klotz SA et al. 2011). Una rassegna delle principali malattie umane associate a Bartonella, delle vie di trasmissione, e delle terapie antibiotiche raccomandate si trova in Tabella 1 (Mogollon-Pasapera E et al. 2009). Come si vede, in funzione della specie di Bartonella coinvolta, le manifestazioni cliniche possono comprendere retiniti, endocarditi, angiomatosi (proliferazione vascolare), la malattia di Carrion (febbre, anemia, ittero), adenopatia, e la febbre quintana (trench fever, febbre alta con mialgie, mal di testa, fatica).
Bartonellosi o borreliosi?
Un recente studio francese ha delineto la possibilità che una malattia cronica caratterizzata da fatica e mialgia, con o senza mal di testa, sia dovuta a una infezione da Bartonella (soprattutto da B. henselae) e sia trasmessa da zecche (Vayssier-Taussat M et al. 2016). Lo studio ha considerato 66 persone che avevano riportato la comparsa di sintomi cronici a seguito di un morso di zecca; i pazienti erano accomunati dal fatto di essere sieronegativi per Borrelia burgdorferi. Il loro sangue è stato sottoposto a coltura per 45 giorni su terreno arricchito da sangue di pecora. Sei dei 66 campioni hanno visto la formazione di colonie batteriche ascrivibili al genere Bartonella: in tre casi si è potuto identificare materiale genetico di B. henselae, negli altri 3 di altre tre specie di Bartonella (Tabella 2). Lo stesso test condotto sul sangue di 70 donatori sani è risultato negativo in ogni campione. Questo studio suggerisce (ma non dimostra) che sintomi aspecifici come fatica e mialgia, a seguito di morso di zecca, possano essere dovuti a una infezione da Bartonella (in particolare B. henselae) piuttosto che essere espressione della malattia di Lyme. Anche Richard Horowitz ha segnalato la possibilità che pazienti con manifestazioni atipiche della malattia di Lyme siano portatori di una infezione da Bartonella, da trattare con cure specifiche (tetraciclina, idrossiclorochina e quinolonico) (Horowitz R, 2014). La presenza di Bartonella henselae nello stomaco di Ixodes ricinus (il vettore della malattia di Lyme in Europa) è stata recentemente riportata in Francia, Portogallo e Germania (Dietrich F et al 2010), ma non in Italia (Mancini F et al. 2014).
In accordo con lo studio francese e le osservazioni di Horowitz, recentemente un articolo proveniente dall’Open Medicine Institute ha segnalato un caso di malattia di Lyme (eritema migrante) refrattario ai trattamenti, caratterizzato da fatica, mal di testa e difficoltà a mantenere l’equilibrio, in cui una coltura su sangue ha evidenziato la presenza di Bartonella henselae. Un trattamento con rifampicina e claritromicina per 5 mesi ha risolto la sintomatologia. Gli autori dello studio hanno sottolineato come la sierologia del paziente per Bartonella fosse negativa, e solo la coltura cellulare di 21 giorni eseguita dal laboratorio Galaxy Diagnostics sia stata in grado di rilevare la infezione da B. henselae (Kauffman DL et al. 2017).
La bartonellosi potrebbe aggiungersi alle infezioni trasmesse dal morso di zecca, sebbene non si abbia ancora la certezza di questo. La malattia si manifesterebbe con sintomi aspecifici quali fatica, mialgie, mal di testa. Non risponderebbe alle cure normalmente utilizzate per Borrelia burgdorferi e quindi potrebbe rendere conto di almeno alcuni dei casi di ‘Lyme cronica’, ovvero di quella condizione refrattaria ai trattamenti, verso cui evolve il 10-20% dei casi di malattia di Lyme.
Nota. Presso l’ospedale Lazzaro Spallanzani di Roma si effettua la PCR per Bartonella spp. su tampone oculare; il tampone, una volta effettuato, deve essere inserito in 1 cc di soluzione fisiologica. Può essere mantenuto a +4-8° prima di essere inviato in laboratorio. Le specie che possono essere identificate con quest’analisi sono le seguenti: B. henselae, B. quintana, B. bacilliformis, B. clarridgeiae, B. elizabethae, B. vinsoni. Non mi è nota la sensibilità di questa procedura diagnostica nei vari tipi di bartonelliosi. La specificità della PCR è in genere molto alta (prossima al 100%).
Considera una donazione per sostenere questo blog.
Il gruppo di Maureen Hanson (Cornell University) ha pubblicato alcuni mesi fa uno studio in cui 361 metaboliti sono stati quantificati nel sangue di 17 donne con ME/CFS (e 15 controlli sani, corrispondenti per sesso ed età) (Germain A et al. 2017). La tecnica utilizzata è la spettroscopia di massa, e questo studio si aggiunge ad altri 3 lavori analoghi sulla ME/CFS pubblicati in questi ultimi 11 mesi (Naviaux R et al. 2016), (Øystein Fluge .et al. 2017), (Yamano E et al. 2016). Lo studio Hanson e lo studio Naviaux sono per ora i due con il maggior numero di metaboliti esaminati e i loro risultati sono coerenti con un complessivo ipometabolismo: circa l’85% dei metaboliti esaminati nei due studi sono ridotti in modo significativo rispetto al controllo sano. I percorsi metabolici coinvolti sono numerosi, dalla ossidazione degli acidi grassi (beta-ossidazione), alla ossidazione degli amminoacidi, alla sintesi di fosfolipidi (i componenti delle membrane cellulari). In figura 1 trovate un confronto fra lo studio Naviaux e lo studio Hanson con analogie e differenze.
I dati grezzi
In questo post non esaminerò lo studio Hanson nel dettaglio, piuttosto voglio proporre una rianalisi statistica di una piccola parte dei dati grezzi, ovvero della misura dei 361 metaboliti nelle 32 persone complessivamente esaminate. I dati sono stati resi disponibili al pubblico (cosa lodevole) in formato .XLSX. Il file è qui.
La mia rianalisi statistica della glicolisi e del ciclo di Krebs
Per la mia analisi statistica dei dati grezzi mi sono concentrato sui percorsi metabolici della glicolisi (piruvato, lattato) e del ciclo di Krebs (aconitato, succinato, fumarato, oxaloacetato). L’analisi si basa sulla assunzione di una distribuzione normale dei valori, utilizzanto il t-test (one-tailed) per il calcolo del valore p. I valori p e le distribuzioni dei dati sono riportati in figura 2. Come si vede, c’è una tendenza all’aumento dei prodotti finali della glicolisi in alcuni pazienti (piruvato, lattato) che tuttavia non è significativa nel complesso. Si apprezza altresì una tendenza alla riduzione dei metaboliti intermedi del ciclo di Krebs, ma solo il succinato e l’oxaloacetato sono ridotti in modo significativo. E’ interessante notare che una tendenza alla riduzione dei metaboliti del ciclo di Krebs è coerente con quanto riportato in (Yamano E et al. 2016) con una metodica simile, e quanto riportato in questo blog, utilizzando la spettroscopia di massa su urine in tre pazienti, due maschi e una femmina (vedi qui).